Can I Use 10w40 Instead Of 15w40: Is it Safe?

10W40 and 15W40 – both belong to the same oil variant. But there are surely some differences between these two popular engine oils. So, using one in place of another might not be the best decision.

So, Can I Use 10w40 Instead Of 15w40: Is it Safe? It’s possible. Although the viscosity means the oil thickness is different, it’s still can be an instant substitute. But for long-term use, it’s not recommended. Doing it too frequently will cause a variety of problems, like lack of lubrication, and premature engine wear.

In this blog post, we’ll dive into the details of these oils and explore whether one may be better suited to your engine than the other.

So, if you’re ready to explore the world of engine oils, let’s get started and find out if you can use 10W40 instead of 15W40.

Also Read: Can You Use 0w40 Instead Of 5w40

Can I Use 10w40 Instead Of 15w40?

Not a good 15w40 alternative, but still, you can use it.

A 10w40 oil flows better at low temperatures compared to a 15w40 oil. However, 15w40 oil maintains a thicker, more stable film of oil at high engine temperatures.

Using 10w40 oil instead of 15w40 means the oil film may get slightly thinner at high temperatures. Considering this, a 10w40 oil should provide sufficient lubrication and protection for most modern-day vehicles.

However, for older engines, heavy-duty use, or extreme climate conditions, the thicker 15w40 oil is usually recommended by vehicle manufacturers. This thicker oil can handle more heat and shear stress without breaking down.

So, which is better, 10w40 or 15w40? Well, it depends on the vehicle you have. A 10w40 oil can be used instead of 15w40 in most everyday passenger vehicle applications. But confirm your owner’s manual if the vehicle requires the more robust 15w40 viscosity for demanding conditions. When in doubt, using the manufacturer’s recommended oil viscosity is wise

10w40 vs 15w40: Comparison Table

Let’s take a look at the core difference between 10w40 and 15w40

Features	10W40	15W40
Viscosity index (VI)	Higher	Lower
Cold temperature flow	Better	Worse
Hot temperature flow	Worse	Better
Fuel efficiency	Higher	Lower
Engine protection	Moderate	Good
Recommended use	Gasoline	Diesel
Oil change frequency	More frequent	Less frequent

Can You Mix 10w40 And 15w40 Oil?

You can mix 10W40 and 15W40 engine oils, provided the specifications and certifications of the oils are the same. For example, mixing one oil that is API SN certified and another that is API SL certified is not recommended.

However, if both oils meet the vehicle manufacturer’s recommended specification, then mixing viscosities such as 10W40 and 15W40 is acceptable. The blend will end up with an intermediate viscosity between the two original oils.

6 Considerations While 10W40 Instead of15W40

Before going to the main discussion, let me emphasize what VI is. It will help you catching the context well.

Viscosity index (VI) is a measure of an oil’s resistance to changes in viscosity at different temperatures.

The higher the VI, the less the oil’s viscosity changes with temperature. 10W40 has a higher VI than 15W40, which means it will maintain its viscosity better over a wider range of temperatures.

This makes it more suitable for engines that operate in a wide range of temperatures, as it provides better protection against wear and tear.

1. Cold Temperature Flow

The first number in an oil’s viscosity rating indicates its ability to flow in cold temperatures. 10W40 has a lower first number than 15W40, which means it flows better in cold temperatures.

This can be beneficial for engines that are started in cold weather, as it ensures that the oil reaches critical engine parts more quickly.

On the other hand, 15W40 may be more suitable for engines that operate in warmer climates, as it offers better protection against high-temperature breakdown.

2. Hot Temperature Flow

The second number in an oil’s viscosity rating indicates its ability to flow at operating temperature. 15W40 has a higher second number than 10W40, which means it offers better protection against high-temperature breakdown.

This makes it more suitable for engines that operate in hot climates, as it reduces the risk of engine damage due to overheating.

However, in cooler climates, 10W40 may be a better choice, as it flows more easily at lower temperatures.

3. Fuel Efficiency

Fuel efficiency is an important consideration for many drivers, as it can affect both performance and cost.

In general, thinner oils tend to offer better fuel efficiency than thicker oils. This means that 10W40 may be more fuel-efficient than 15W40, although the difference may be negligible in some cases.

4. Engine Protection

Engine protection is perhaps the most important factor to consider when choosing an engine oil. Both 10W40 and 15W40 offer good engine protection, but there are some differences.

15W40 may be more suitable for diesel engines, as it offers better protection against soot and other contaminants.

On the other hand, 10W40 may be more suitable for gasoline engines, as it offers better protection against deposits and sludge.

5. Recommended Use

It’s important to choose an engine oil that is recommended for your specific vehicle. In general, 15W40 is more commonly used in diesel engines, while 10W40 is more commonly used in gasoline engines.

However, there may be exceptions, and it’s always important to refer to your vehicle manufacturer’s recommendations.

6. Oil Change Frequency

Finally, it’s important to consider how often you’ll need to change your engine oil.

In general, thicker oils tend to break down more slowly than thinner oils, which means that 15W40 may require less frequent oil changes than 10W40.

However, the exact oil change frequency will depend on a variety of factors, including the vehicle’s age, mileage, and usage.

Understanding the Shared Characteristics of 10W40 and 15W40 Engine Oils

While there are some differences between 10W40 and 15W40 engine oils, there are also several similarities. Here are some of the key similarities:

1. SAE Rating: Both 10W40 and 15W40 engine oils are rated according to the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) viscosity rating system. This means that both oils have been tested and approved according to a standardized system, which makes it easier for drivers to choose the right oil for their vehicle.
2. Engine Protection: Both 10W40 and 15W40 engine oils offer good engine protection. They are designed to lubricate engine parts, reduce wear and tear, and prevent damage from contaminants and debris. This means that drivers can trust both oils to help keep their engines running smoothly and efficiently.
3. Recommended Use: While 15W40 is generally recommended for diesel engines and 10W40 for gasoline engines, both oils can be used in a variety of engines. In fact, many modern engines are designed to be compatible with both oils. This means that drivers have some flexibility when it comes to choosing an engine oil.
4. Availability: Both 10W40 and 15W40 engine oils are widely available at auto parts stores, service centers, and online retailers. This means that drivers can easily find the oil they need, no matter where they are.

FAQ’s

End Note

Whether to use 10W40 or 15W40 engine oil depends on your specific engine’s requirements. It is crucial to refer to the owner’s manual and use the recommended viscosity rating to ensure optimal performance and protection for your engine.

While 10W40 and 15W40 engine oils share some similarities, such as similar base oil and additive composition, they also have significant differences in cold and high-temperature performance, fuel economy, and compatibility with different engine types.

FYI, read our other motor oil comparison here –

• Can You Use 15w40 Instead of 10w30
• Can I Use 85w140 instead Of 75w90
• Use 75w90 Instead Of 75w85
• Can you Use 10w40 instead of 5w20
• Can I Use 85w140 instead of 80w90
• Can You Use 85w140 Instead of 75w140
• Can I Use 10w50 instead of 10w40